Jake’s 58 Hotel & Casino is a machine-focused casino hotel in Islandia, New York, near the Long Island Expressway. Its strongest reason to visit is convenience: electronic gaming, dinner, and a hotel room in one Long Island stop. The main limitation is that this is not a traditional live-dealer casino or an amenity-heavy resort. I’d shortlist it for local machine players and adults planning an overnight gambling outing, with one practical warning: free parking does not necessarily mean easy parking.
Jake’s 58 at a glance
| Location | 3635 Expressway Drive North, Islandia, NY 11749 |
|---|---|
| Casino type | Electronic-gaming casino with an attached hotel |
| Operator | Suffolk Regional Off-Track Betting |
| Advertised gaming inventory | Approximately 1,000 machines, including slots and electronic table games |
| Minimum gambling age | 18 |
| Live-dealer tables | No |
| Poker room | No |
| Retail sportsbook | No |
| Hotel | 200 rooms; adults only |
| Check-in / check-out | 4 p.m. / 11 a.m. |
| Hotel check-in age | 21; additional overnight guests must be at least 18 |
| Self-parking | Free; availability is not guaranteed |
| Smoking | Smoking and vaping prohibited |
| Dining | Bistro58, a bar, and lobby grab-and-go service |
| Rewards program | The Club |
Information as of October 23, 2026. Announced expansion facilities are not included as operating amenities.
What kind of casino is Jake’s 58?
Think of Jake’s 58 as a Long Island gambling stop with bedrooms attached, rather than a resort that happens to have a casino. Its Islandia location is the attraction for visitors who would otherwise organize a longer casino trip.
If machines are your main interest, the electronic format may suit you perfectly well. If your casino evening revolves around dealers, chips, and a lively craps table, this is the wrong game plan. For alternatives, see our guide to New York casinos.
Slots, video poker, and electronic table games
The property advertises approximately 1,000 slot machines and electronic table games. That is the combined inventory, not 1,000 slots plus a separate collection of tables.
Slots and video poker
Slots are central to the visit. Check the actual minimum wager and any credits required to qualify for bonus features or jackpots. A penny denomination is not a promise of a penny spin.
For video poker, inspect the variation and displayed pay table rather than relying on the cabinet’s name. If a particular game or denomination is essential to your trip, ask about current availability before traveling.
I would not choose this casino because somebody called its machines “loose,” or avoid it because somebody called them “tight.” A guest’s winning or losing session is not a measurement of the next player’s prospects.
Table games are electronic, not live dealer
Jake’s 58 does not offer traditional live-dealer tables. Its table-style gaming is electronic, so do not expect a staffed blackjack pit or conventional dealer-operated roulette.
Electronic play may suit someone who prefers a self-directed experience, but rules and payouts still deserve attention. Read the terminal’s information before betting rather than assuming it duplicates a familiar live game.
Poker room and sportsbook
Jake’s 58 has no dedicated player-versus-player poker room and no on-property retail sportsbook. Video poker is a machine game, not a cash game or tournament against other players. A possible future sportsbook has been discussed, but it is not a current betting facility.
Expansion plans: what is not open yet?
Expansion announcements can make Jake’s 58 sound larger than the casino available today. In an October 14, 2026, South Shore Press interview, Suffolk OTB President and CEO Phil Boyle described a new casino building intended eventually to house 2,000 gaming machines. He gave a hoped-for mid-December opening, possibly later, rather than a confirmed opening date.
The planned addition of 1,000 terminals represents a 100% increase over the advertised 1,000-machine inventory. It is a substantial expansion, but not a reason to count 2,000 playable machines before the additional capacity opens.
Additional dining, a sports bar or sportsbook, and other amenities were discussed as possibilities for a later phase. My advice: book for the facilities operating on your dates, not the rendering.
Hotel: rooms, age requirements, and booking policies
The attached 200-room hotel makes its strongest case when gambling is the main evening activity. You can have dinner, play, and finish the night without another drive. If most of your itinerary is elsewhere on Long Island, compare accommodation closer to those plans.
Casino admission and machine play start at 18, but hotel check-in requires age 21. That three-year difference means being old enough to gamble does not make you eligible to check in yourself. Additional overnight guests must be at least 18, and children are not allowed.
- Arrival and departure: Check-in is at 4 p.m.; check-out is at 11 a.m.
- Identification: All hotel guests need government-issued photo identification.
- Incidentals: An accepted credit card is required for a deposit. Do not rely on a digital wallet.
- Cancellation: The published policy requires cancellation at least 24 hours before arrival to avoid a one-night penalty. Reservations with deposits require contacting the front desk.
- Room amenities: Wireless internet, cable television, air conditioning, and housekeeping upon request.
Arrange essential accessibility features directly rather than treating a special request as a guarantee. KAYAK’s automated summary of guest reviews highlights complaints about slow or out-of-service elevators. Those reports do not establish current conditions, but if stairs would be difficult, ask about elevator availability before booking.
Compare the final room total, cancellation terms, and incidental hold before deciding whether the convenience is worth the price. Extra-person charges may apply.
For a weekday overnight, the official Stay & Play offer advertises a room-rate discount plus $25 in slot play, valid Sunday through Thursday. Compare its final total with the ordinary room rate, and read the promotional-play conditions before treating it as the better deal.
Restaurants and bars
Bistro58 is the full-service restaurant, with published hours of 11 a.m. to midnight. Its bar serves cocktails and wine, closing at midnight Sunday through Thursday and at 2 a.m. Friday and Saturday.
That gives the weekend bar a two-hour later closing time, but does not extend the restaurant’s published schedule. I would settle dinner plans before settling into a late session.
The lobby grab-and-go outlet advertises coffee, espresso, milkshakes, smoothies, sandwiches, and baked goods, with published hours of 6:30 a.m. to 3 a.m. Check the official dining page for service times before your visit.
The appeal is keeping the outing in one building, not choosing among a sprawling resort’s restaurants. Make separate plans for non-gambling entertainment rather than assuming a major show or extensive leisure facilities will fill the evening.
Directions, parking, and practical visit advice
Use 3635 Expressway Drive North, Islandia, NY 11749 for navigation. The property is near Exit 58 of the Long Island Expressway. On Long Island, I would pay more attention to the live traffic estimate than the mileage.
Self-parking is free, but availability is a separate question. Parking pressure was acknowledged by the operator in the October expansion interview. Do not treat the approved overflow lot as available until it opens.
Allow arrival time beyond the drive itself, particularly if dinner or hotel check-in anchors your evening. If you plan to drink, arrange your room or return transportation beforehand.
- Bring government-issued photo identification.
- Smoking and vaping are prohibited.
- Photography and video are not allowed on the casino floor.
- Confirm casino hours before an early-morning or late-night trip rather than assuming round-the-clock gaming.
Keep transportation, meals, drinks, and hotel charges separate from your gambling bankroll. Free parking is a useful saving, not a reason to increase your loss limit.
The Club rewards program
The Club is free to join and advertises food-and-beverage point redemption, promotions, drawings, and giveaways. Ask how eligible play is tracked before starting, and read the conditions attached to individual offers.
My rule is to collect benefits on play you already intended to make. Playing longer to chase an offer can turn a modest perk into an expensive purchase.
Who Jake’s 58 is best for
Jake’s 58 suits Long Island machine players who want gambling, dinner, and an adults-only hotel stay in one place, with free self-parking and a nonsmoking policy adding practical appeal. I would choose it for convenience rather than a resort vacation, while allowing extra arrival time because parking pressure and expansion work can complicate that convenience. Visitors seeking live-dealer action or a broad selection of non-gambling attractions should choose a property built around those priorities instead.
Frequently asked questions
How old do you have to be to gamble at Jake’s 58?
You must be at least 18 to enter the casino floor and play its video gaming machines. Hotel check-in requires age 21, and additional overnight guests must be at least 18.
Does Jake’s 58 have live table games?
No. Table-style gaming is electronic rather than live dealer.
Does Jake’s 58 have a poker room or sportsbook?
No. It has neither a dedicated player-versus-player poker room nor an on-property retail sportsbook.
How many gaming machines does Jake’s 58 have?
The property advertises approximately 1,000 machines, including slots and electronic table games. The planned 2,000-machine total is not the operating inventory described here.
Is parking free at Jake’s 58?
Yes, self-parking is free, but a space is not guaranteed.
Is Jake’s 58 suitable for a family stay?
No. The hotel is adults only, and children are not allowed.
Can you smoke or vape inside?
No. The property prohibits smoking and vaping.
Poker room and sportsbook
There is no dedicated poker room or on-site sportsbook.